The american patriots in the thirteen colonies defeated the british in the american revolutionary war 17751783 with the assistance of france, winning independence from great britain and establishing the united states of america the american colonials proclaimed no taxation without representation. French revolution success or failure essay example. Which would make an effective thesis for an on the cause of the french revolution. Why was the american revolution so much more successful in.
As englands american colonies became ever more rebellious in the 1760s and 1770s, france was naturally predisposed to favor the american revolutionaries and saw an opportunity to try to blunt the power of its longtime adversary. The american revolution of 17751789 was probably the most significant of these influences. The american revolution was more sucessful than the. The french revolution of 17891799 was moderately successful in its attempt to achieve its goals for the lower class of france. Even so, american generals nathanael greene and daniel morgan turned to guerrilla and hitandrun warfare that eventually stymied the british. The french revolution was influenced by the political experiences and systems of other nations. Thks happened multiple times during the french revolution.
In this way, the french revolution was extremely successful. France and the united kingdom were great powers in the 1700s, and they often clashed in their quest for lucrative colonies. Both the american revolution and french revolution were the products of enlightenment ideals that emphasized the idea of natural rights and equality. While there have been numerous revolutions throughout the course of history, the two most arguably prominent revolutions remain to be the american revolution and the french revolution. British to view the revolution more in terms of how it affected them than on its. The american and french revolutions were similar in several ways. The french revolutionists aimed to obtain greater power for the third estate, to break the absolutism of the french monarchy and topple the aristocracy, introduce a constitution to limit the power of the upper class in the making of decisions for the country and for. Revolutions in other countries, discontent people from all classes, and passionate revolutionaries were among the factors that led to a successful r. The french revolution failed because removing those in power without replacing them with a proper leader is basically asking for a more corrupt leader to take over.
French revolution, revolutionary movement that shook france between 1787 and 1799 and reached its first climax there in 1789hence the conventional term revolution of 1789, denoting the end of the ancien regime in france and serving also to distinguish that event from the later french. The american and french revolutions both compare and contrast in their origins and outcomes. Yet regardless, a main contributing factor to both questions are the many fundamental differences between the two nations. With such an ideological basis, it becomes clear when one sets out to compare the french revolution and american revolution that people felt the need to be free from oppressive or tyrannical rule.
The neolithic revolution, a widescale transition of. Success of the mexican revolution essayswhy was the first mexican revolution successful. It began in 1775 with the american revolution, in which the british colonies in north america fought for their independence from britain. Napoleon was a good leader at the start, but he became a dictator that took france down with him in his quest for immortality. The presences of colonial legislatures meant that the colonies were in many ways independent of the crown. The american revolution had clear goals, did not spiral out of control, and accomplished what it set out to do. While the french revolution was a complex conflict with numerous triggers and. Strangely, french king louis xvi himself triggered the french revolution by holding the first session of frances parliament or estates general in 175 years. Why the american revolution was more successful in establishing a republic than the french revolution and why the american revolution didnt create an emperor are two very different questions. More importantly, he solidified a favorable american view of france.
Both revolutions were to protest the form of government known as a monarchy or king. Unlike the american revolution, the french revolution led to efforts to create a wholly new society, symbolized by such things as a new calendar, a new. The french revolution was based on an assortment of enlightenment ideals. The american revolution occurred in an area that was an ocean away from its ruling monarchy in britain. Why did the french revolution fail and the american. The causes of the american revolution digital history. The french and american revolutions are both very significant in the worlds history.
American revolution, french revolution, theories of revolution, human rights, religion, freedom. Thus the american revolution, from which little was expected, produced much. Even if only because the french revolution was at the heart of europe and was carried to all its neighbours by force, while the nascent united states was rather more distant. The american revolution happened first, around the last half of the 18th century where the thirteen colonies became the united states of america, and gained independence from the british empire. Most of our textbooks and popular treatises, however, have continued to. The french revolution was more violent than the american revolution because it was a more typical revolution that pitted classes of people against each other. The most famous was lafayette, a charming young aristocrat who defied the kings order and enlisted in. Because the french revolution devolved into revolution for the sake of revolution. The american revolution faired much better because they kept most of their power structure in place afterwards. The violence took on a life of its own and was a direct cause of napoleon bonapartes rise to power. The war followed more than a decade of growing estrangement between the british crown and many north american colonists.
Many factors made the first mexican revolution successful. British protection by the removal of the french menace from. In comparing the two revolutions, it becomes clear there is a fundamental differences in the way frustration with authority manifested itself. The french revolution was defeated but the revolution was victorious. The legacy of the american revolution, and of the entire political tradition associated with it, is problematic in all sorts of ways.
British military power gradually stripped france of many of her colonies, most notably the. This article surveys the significance of the american and french revolutions in the modern social sciences. The seven years war known in america as the french and indian war changed everything. The american revolution was a success, in arendts eyes, because it. In both countries, the king had complete control and the citizens had almost no voice.
Thus, this discourse will show an analysis of the two revolutions. France in the american revolutionary war wikipedia. The french revolution, by contrast, illuminated by americas example and enlightenment thought, began in blissful optimism but collapsed into a bloodsoaked tyranny much worse than the monarchy it deposed. The american revolution, on the other hand, was distinguished by its alleged conservatism. All of this and more contributed to the french revolution not being quite as revolutionary as it could have been. Choose from 500 different sets of vocabulary french american revolution flashcards on quizlet.
So there is a truth to the idea of an influential american revolution. The french revolutionaries perceived themselves as starting from scratch in recreating the social order, while the americans sought to restore or build upon earlier freedoms. Lessons modern america can learn from the french revolution lesson one. The british were successful in most conventional battles fought in that region, especially in areas close to their points of supply on the atlantic coast. The american revolution timeline covers the lead up to the revolution, key battles, and the formation. Both american and french revolutions were characterized by a large number of deaths from both sides of the warring parties. So, the american and french revolutions launched an historic struggle between two conceptions and two sets of principles.
How france helped win the american revolution american. In 1775, after a decade of political tension, the british colonies in eastern north america rebelled and declared their independence from the mother country. What was one consequence of the fighting between neighbors and within families during the american revolution. Few attempts at ingratiation have been more true or more damning. In which john green examines the french revolution, and gets into how and why it differed from the american revolution. French revolution dbq the french revolution started in 1789 and ended in 1799.
French philosophers, including voltaire and rousseau led the revolution leading up to the revolution, so to speak, coming up with progressive ideals as to government, social structure, and the nature of people. Essay by silverstorm2k5, high school, 10th grade, february 2005 download word file, 2 pages download word file, 2 pages 3. But in the context of eighteenth and nineteenthcentury politics, the american revolution was dwarfed in importance by the french revolution, which laid the foundation for radical, secular, and bloody revolutions that would become common in the centuries to follow. In the american revolution, there were more than 100,000 reported casualties while the french revolution is said to have published almost the same number of victims from both sides of the conflicting parties. Rhode island in the american revolution 2000 download. The american revolution was triggered by the american. As a result, the american revolution was able to succeed where the french revolution failed. How did the american revolution influence the french. Comparing the american, french and haitian revolutions by. It was a clear action directly threatening the french monarchy. The american revolution american memory timeline classroom. American vs french revolution the imaginative conservative. After the american revolution came many others, but the one that stands out the most is the french revolution.
The american revolution was a successful revolution, but there is no such thing, either in ones personal life or in a nations history, as unambiguous success. Similarities between french and american revolution. Attempts to raise taxes in great britain had resulted in the famous. French involvement in the american revolutionary war of 17751783 began in 1775, when france, a hotbed of enlightenment liberal ideologies and the archnemesis of the british empire, secretly shipped supplies to the continental army established in june 1775. The first topic of conversation was the french and american revolutions. The haitian revolution lasted from 1791 to 1804 and resulted in the independence of the french slave colony. British spectators of the french revolution university of groningen. The presence of colonial legislatures, the ideologies presented by the enlightenment philosophers, and the salutary neglect are all causes of revolution. Infesting intellectuals everywhere, its ideas eventuated in the successful russian revolution. The american revolution had very important social causes.
The consequences of things are not always proportionate to the apparent magnitude of those events that have produced them. A revolution is defined as an overthrow or repudiation through replacement of an established government or political system by the people governed. Essay the french revolution and the american revolution. The french revolution was a watershed event in modern european history that began in 1789 and ended in the late 1790s with the ascent of napoleon bonaparte. Why was the american revolution more successful then the. It began providing covert support beginning with badly needed gunpowder in the spring of 1776. A comparison of the french revolution and american revolution. American, french, and haitian revolutions test study guide learn vocabulary french american revolution with free interactive flashcards. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. French revolution it is obvious that the french revolution was a vaster and more profound social upheaval, involving more violent conflict between classes, more radical reorganization of government and s. In your opinion, what was the most important decision the second continental congress made. But how is the american revolution taught in the uk and in other countries around the world. It all began with the extravagant spendings of king louis and marie antoinette, the bankruptcy, the poor harvest, the rises in bread and taxes, and lastly, american revolution.
Why was the french revolution more violent than the. This continental victory convinced the french to enter the war against britain during the. The british were successful in most conventional battles fought in that region, especially in areas close. The american revolution and the french revolution are similar in many ways, yet they are different. After violence broke out between britain and its american colonies in 1775, delegates. As far as european history goes, the french revolution is far more. How did the french revolution enter a new phase after the storming of the bastille essay pages. W hy was the american revolution, of all great revolutions, the only successful one, resulting in two centuries and more of unexampled freedom and prosperity. While the french revolution was a complex conflict with numerous triggers and causes, the american revolution set the stage for an effective uprising that the french had observed firsthand. Pdf american and french revolutions and their impact on. The united states, the french revolution, and liberalism. The second continental congress article khan academy. The americans most successful raid against the occupying forces occurred on. Pdf american and french revolutions and their impact on the.
The american revolution was a colonial revolt which occurred between 1765 and 1783. The american, french, and haitian revolutions all achieved their initial. The american revolution was more sucessful than the british and french revolution. American revolution 177583, insurrection by which of great britains north american colonies won political independence and went on to form the united states of america. French involvement in the american revolutionary war of 17751783 began in 1775, when.
How did the american revolution influence the french revolution. The american revolution has many parallels with the french revolution. Reviving old and unfamiliar political institutions can be fatal. I believe i suggested that the french revolution is, in terms of world history, more important and more globally significant than the american revolution. The american and the french revolutions 1816 words cram. British military power gradually stripped france of many of her colonies, most notably the british conquest of canada in 1759. Which revolution was more successful the american or the.
976 1657 1451 1665 1331 484 441 566 1405 820 88 945 1263 1642 1283 447 719 1058 1079 64 1036 1010 868 477 1120 1197 534 942 766 919 224 1347 1295 535 732 463 779 277 158 958